Recently, the world was introduced to Caitlyn Jenner; the Olympic Gold Medalist is bringing the term transgender into news feeds everywhere. So, how does being transgender pertain to life insurance?
Just like people, insurance companies have many differences, and life insurance policies are not one-size fits-all. Generally, when someone applies for life insurance, if their assigned sex at birth was female, they should apply as female, and if their assigned sex at birth was male, they should apply as male. This would include individuals whose gender identity differs from their assigned sex at birth, but who have not undergone any medical or physical transition. When a person is or has used hormone therapy treatment and/or has had any gender affirming surgeries, it will not only affect the rates for which they apply, it may also affect the requirements needed during the underwriting process.
Recently, we worked with an applicant who had surgically transitioned from male to female. We completed an underwriting study, which is when we go to the carriers and ask what they think they could offer our applicant, and the responses varied. Some carrier responses included the following*:
- We may issue Standard male rates assuming no history of depression, anxiety or other issues.
- We may issue Preferred male rates pending on medical history.
- We may issue Preferred female rates pending medical records and that applicant is following post-surgery requirements such as counseling and hormone therapy.
- We cannot issue until 3 years post-surgery and would rate as female then.
- We would generally issue male rates, but will consider female if applicant feels it’s more appropriate.
- Whatever gender the applicant applies as is the one we will use.
- We always underwrite as the gender they were born with.
As you can see, no two insurance carriers are alike. Each company follows their own set of underwriting guidelines and works on a case-by-case basis. It is our drive at Quotacy to help you find the life insurance policy that fits you best.
Life insurance is important for everyone who has loved ones that depend upon them. Quotacy will shop your case with our many life insurance carriers to help you get the best policy for your individual situation. Life insurance offers great peace of mind knowing your loved ones will be protected when you are not around to do so. Take a moment to get free term life insurance quotes and see how little it could cost you to protect the ones you love most.
*Please note: The statements are the un-edited responses of underwriters at some of our carriers and do not reflect the views of Quotacy as a company.
Photo credit to ajusticenetwork
Related Posts:
Term Life Insurance for Couples
My wife and I are the same age. We have had a term life insurance policy for a couple of decades now. Our policies’ face value is the same. We are both non-smokers, in excellent health. Her monthly premium as a female is 40% less than mine.
According to some of the company responses given above, a biological male (aka, a “man”) can walk into some insurance companies, attest that he is a female (“woman”), and on that criteria alone, some companies will charge HIM the lower premium rate.
If I discover that my life insurance company has this practice, why would I not have grounds for a discrimination lawsuit? And, why would I not be entitled to a refund, with interest, for ALL the increased premium payments I have made over the last two decades?
Trust me: I’m going to check into this. Meanwhile, we all would be well advised to recognize that Insurance companies, like medical professionals, can’t afford to be in the business of treating customers/patients according to their subjective “identity” games.
If you “identify” as a non-smoker and receive a lower premium rate, once your insurer discovers that you are, in fact, a smoker, your policy will likely be cancelled. As it should be.
Hello,
Thank you for your comment. Life insurance is an underwritten contract which means the insurance companies ultimately do discriminate risk and then price according to mortality rates. Short way of saying that men pay more than women, smokers pay more than non-smokers, and people with health challenges tend to pay more than people who are given a clean bill of health by their doctor.
It is important to clarify that the example we referred to in the blog is based on an individual who had surgery to transition from male to female, not someone identifying as a different gender whom has not gone through the gender-affirming surgery. That would be underwritten entirely differently and most insurance companies would underwrite their gender based on their birth certificate.
Gender transitioning is a very complicated process, financially, legally, physically and emotionally, so there are many factors in play when underwriting an individual for life insurance. Many individuals participate in counseling, hormone therapy, and are on a number of prescribed medications, and all of these factors are likely to affect how they are underwritten and therefore affect what premiums they would be required to pay. So while someone who transitioned from male to female may be able to be underwritten as female with some companies, and ergo receive female prices, their premiums likely will be raised based on the other factors. So, insurance companies do balance out the risk they take by insuring transgender applicants.
This amazes me, do these people realise it’s the 21st Century! As a fit & healthy Trans Woman who has yet to undergo GRS (I do gym/PT sessions 4x/week and also do MMA) I am finding it almost impossible to find an accepting Underwriting Co. Wake up folks!!
Hi Paula,
When was the last time you tried applying for life insurance? If it has been awhile I encourage you to try it again. Life insurance carriers will look at your medical history, current medications, family history and a variety of other factors and then underwrite you based on risk alone. You being fit and healthy definitely helps!
We work with multiple life insurance carriers and will do everything we can to help you get coverage if you would like to try again with us this time around. You can start by running a term quote or contact us directly.